The Commonwealth of Virginia's Ultimate Blog

Tuesday, April 12, 2005

Steve Baril and Bob McDonnell debate Terry Schiavo

Well, not so much, according to this WaPo article:
Referring to the controversy over the fate of Terri Schiavo, the Florida woman who died at a hospice 13 days after her feeding tube was removed, Gilmore asked the candidates, "Should a disabled person like this ever be denied food and water and starved to death and die of thirst, even if it's in a medical directive?"

Both said that living wills should be used to determine end-of-life treatment decisions, but that when there is doubt about what a patient would have wanted, doctors should take life-saving measures.

"Without the ability of the government to protect human life, all other rights do not exist," McDonnell said.

Baril suggested that the attorney general could find a role in such cases by examining whether to appoint an independent guardian. He said lawyers should encourage people to put their wishes in writing.
The biggest bone of contention continues to be whose background has been better preparation for the job.
The two clashed most, however, on issues of biography. Richmond lawyer Steve Baril said his legal credentials make him better qualified to be the state's top attorney, and Del. Robert F. McDonnell of Virginia Beach countered that his experiences as a state politician, former prosecutor and Army veteran give him the edge.
I have to say that I disagree with the implication that small-firm lawyers don't get the training they need to become AG. I would be interested in hearing Steve Minor's thoughts on the issue.

6 Comments:

Blogger Steve said...

I can't say that it's true that small firm lawyers are unqualified to be AG. I would argue that there have been no big firm lawyers who have been elected AG, although some of them (Miller, Baliles, Gilmore) became big firm lawyers afterwards. (I think of Kilgore as a SW Virginia lawyer.) The last big firm nominee, Dolan, lost in part because Gilmore ran ads claiming that Dolan "botched" his only criminal prosecution. Criminal law experience might count more with voters.

I would want the AG to be a good lawyer, but there are all kinds of lawyers. The big firm litigators are more likely to be involved in interesting, complex civil matters involving big businesses. The smaller firm lawyers are closer to the ground, representing more people and smaller businesses. Even those generalizations have their limits.

Here's an awkward example: you can get on Westlaw and see how many times a lawyer's name is on there associated with the opinions in the database for the state and federal courts in Virginia. Baril's name is there 26 times, McDonnell's name is there 3 times, and mine is there 44 times. Who is most qualified to be AG? Not I.

Besides, the AG is more than a lawyer. No lawyer in private practice will learn all the substantive areas of the law touched by the workings of the AG's office - there's too much to know. And, he doesn't have to know it - the AG has hundreds of lawyers working under him. The selection of AG is more like hiring a coach than picking a quarterback.

And so, the more important difference between candidates might be their ideas. The AG gets to choose the legal position of the Commonwealth on many kinds of legal matters, including disputed social issues. The AG also has a role in the shaping the justice system for all Virginians. It is interesting to me to learn what priorities and perspectives the different candidates bring to those tasks.

2:09 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

i think she suffereeed enough!!!!!!!!!!

11:40 AM

 
Blogger Steve Austin said...

I like your blog. Check out my free bankruptcy form blog.

1:33 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

“We cannot live for ourselves alone. Our lives are connected by a thousand invisible threads, and along these sympathetic fibers, our actions run as causes and return to us as results.”
- Herman Melville

RSS is the way of the Future...
my yahoo rss

8:44 AM

 
Blogger hiro said...

I've stumbled across your blog when I done some brain injury lawyer research in Google. You're doing a pretty nice job
here, keep up the good work! check out brain injury lawyer

8:00 AM

 
Blogger Tom Naka said...

We had been blogging trying to find how our world sees health male sexual
. It has been a lifeline for us. Your site provides some of the best examples of this sort and we will bookmark yours. Another one we found was and appears to be related to yours is health male sexual
site/blog. It pretty much covers health male sexual
related stuff.

3:47 AM

 

Post a Comment

<< Home